Gaylord won league title
| Defensive Back | Ford Richardson | Senior | Marquette | 1st Team |
| Defensive Back | Clayton Edwards | Junior | Marquette | 1st Team |
| Defensive Back | Mason Silsbury | Senior | Gaylord | 1st Team |
| Defensive Back | Brian Boutilier | Senior | Escanaba | 2nd Team |
| Defensive Back | Halan McCollum | Senior | Marquette | 2nd Team |
| Defensive Back | Braden Fralick | Sophomore | Petoskey | 2nd Team |
| Defensive Back | Johnnie Daniels | Junior | Cadillac | HM |
| Defensive Back | Hayden Groves | Senior | Gaylord | HM |
| Defensive Back | Dane Armentrout | Sophomore | Sault Ste. Marie | HM |
| Linebacker | Jaron Bensinger | Senior | Gaylord | 1st Team |
| Linebacker | Brody Ison | Junior | Escanaba | 1st team |
| Linebacker | Sam Ingalls | Senior | Petoskey | 1st Team |
| Linebacker | Keagan Braun | Senior | Escanaba | 1st Team |
| Linebacker | Aiden Aube | Senior | Alpena | 2nd Team |
| Linebacker | Max Narovich | Junior | Cadillac | 2nd Team |
| Linebacker | Beckett Blake | Senior | Petoskey | 2nd Team |
| Linebacker | Finn Miller | Senior | Gaylord | 2nd Team |
| Linebacker | Marc DeWildt | Senior | Sault Ste. Marie | HM |
| Linebacker | Xavier Szymoniak | Sophomore | Alpena | HM |
| Defensive Line | Jace Shaw | Junior | Petoskey | 1st Team |
| Defensive Line | Rocky Sholl | Junior | Marquette | 1st Team |
| Defensive Line | Cameron Kade | Sophomore | Cadillac | 1st Team |
| Defensive Line | Taylor Asgaard | Senior | Escanaba | 1st Team |
| Defensive Line | Hudson Derry | Junior | Alpena | 2nd Team |
| Defensive Line | Broden Biller | Senior | Cadillac | 2nd Team |
