• Home
  • News
    • UP 200
    • Local
    • Lansing Bureau
    • Washington D.C. Bureau
    • National
    • Insights
    • Watch 19 News Live
    • CBS News Live
    • Report News
  • Weather
    • Forecast + Conditions
    • Current Alerts
    • Interactive Radar
    • Cameras
    • Share Photos/Videos
    • Closings and Delays
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Life in the 906
    • The Yooper Goddess
WZMQ 19 News | CBS | MeTV Marquette
Mostly Cloudy

Marquette
Mostly Cloudy 37°

Cloudy

Escanaba
Cloudy 41°

Cloudy

Houghton
Cloudy 45°

Cloudy

Iron Mountain
Cloudy 43°

Watch
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • UP 200
    • Local
    • Lansing Bureau
    • Washington D.C. Bureau
    • National
    • Insights
    • Watch 19 News Live
    • CBS News Live
    • Report News
  • Weather
    • Forecast + Conditions
    • Current Alerts
    • Interactive Radar
    • Cameras
    • Share Photos/Videos
    • Closings and Delays
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Life in the 906
    • The Yooper Goddess
WZMQ 19 News | CBS | MeTV Marquette
No Result
View All Result
WZMQ 19 News | CBS | MeTV Marquette
No Result
View All Result

Legal experts: Crumbley Parents’ trials set new factual precedent

by Sophia Murphy
February 14, 2024 - Updated on February 16, 2024
A A

LANSING, Mich. (WZMQ) – In a first-of-its-kind verdict, last month Jennifer Crumbley was found guilty on four counts of involuntary manslaughter in connection to the shooting her son, Ethan Crumbly, committed at Oxford High School in 2021.

In December, Ethan Crumbley was sentenced to life without parole for killing four of his classmates and injuring others in the 2021 Oxford shooting. Durring the hearing information came out that Ethan’s parents were aware he had been struggling mentally, but still purchased and allowed him access to a firearm. This led prosecutors to build a case against Crumbley’s parents.

That argument is what made the jury hand down a guilty verdict to Jennifer Crumbley on four counts of involuntary manslaughter. Jurors said the deciding factor was evidence that showed she had been the last person to access the firearm.

Professor Tonya Krause-Phelan, Associate Dean of Academics at Cooley Law School, explained that there are two kinds of legal precedents. The first is a legally binding precedent, usually set by an Appellate or State Supreme Court. The other is what Krause-Phalen said is coming into play in this case, a factual precedent.

“Factually it’s a precedent that will establish how people handle these kinds of investigations and prosecutions in the future. Legally, it’s not a binding precedent, yet.” Krause-Phalen said. “Going forward, they’re going to conduct investigations in the same manner. they may consider similar arguments if they decide to try parents and caregivers, or people who had custody and control over a minor child who committed a shooting.”

Krause-Phalen explained the precedent could mean investigators take a deeper dive into the student or family background, socials, and school records.

Krause-Phalen said a common criticism has been how this precedent may be more loosely applied to convict other parents of their child’s crimes. She explained that cases like this have strict applications, saying the facts of this case were extreme, and any future application would have to would have to be a very similar situation. 

“In this particular case, there were some pretty egregious facts as to what the child was demonstrating from a mental health perspective, what the parents were aware of, and what the parents chose not to do anything about.”

Krause-Phalen says that despite similar evidence for Crumbley’s father, with a different defense team and jury, the verdits may still end up different. The hearing for James Crumbley has yet to start, he’s set to stand trial on March 5th.

Get WZMQ 19 anytime, anywhere

Download the app

AppleAndroid

Watch on TV

RokuFire TVZeam

Connect on social media

FacebookTwitterInstagram

More

Dr Abdul El-Sayed is taking his campaign on the road with his "Open Our Health Care" tour kicking off here in the U.P. and stretching across Michigan.
News

U.S. Senate candidate El-Sayed visits Marquette

October 21, 2025
News

Michigan House Passes Three Tax Bills in First Session Back After Budget Vote

October 21, 2025
News

Escanaba Artwalk to showcase local artists at downtown businesses

October 21, 2025
Members gather for a Men's Circle weekend kickoff
News

Up North Advocacy broadens men’s mental health awareness with ‘Men’s Circles’ program

October 21, 2025
News

Department of Attorney General assumes prosecutorial duties in Luce County

October 21, 2025
News

Construction worker killed in M-553 crash

October 21, 2025
Next Post
New Conservation District Manager Heather LeDuc

New Delta Conservation District manager hopes to reach more of the community

Lieutenant Governor Gilchrist II champions cybersecurity apprenticeship program during Iron Mountain visit

  • Home
  • News
  • Weather
  • Sports
  • Features
  • Events
  • Programming
  • Station
WZMQ CBS | 19 News

© 2025 WZMQ, LLC | FCC Public File | EEO Report

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • UP 200
    • Local
    • Lansing Bureau
    • Washington D.C. Bureau
    • National
    • Insights
    • Watch 19 News Live
    • CBS News Live
    • Report News
  • Weather
    • Forecast + Conditions
    • Current Alerts
    • Interactive Radar
    • Cameras
    • Share Photos/Videos
    • Closings and Delays
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Life in the 906
    • The Yooper Goddess
  • Events
  • Programming
    • Programming Guide
    • CBS
    • MeTV
    • Start TV
    • Heroes & Icons
    • Court TV
    • ION
  • Station
    • About Us
    • Community Involvement
    • Mobile App
    • Meet the Team
    • Contact
    • Careers
    • Advertising
    • Request Copy of Story
    • FCC Public File
    • EEO Report
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • UP 200
    • Local
    • Lansing Bureau
    • Washington D.C. Bureau
    • National
    • Insights
    • Watch 19 News Live
    • CBS News Live
    • Report News
  • Weather
    • Forecast + Conditions
    • Current Alerts
    • Interactive Radar
    • Cameras
    • Share Photos/Videos
    • Closings and Delays
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Life in the 906
    • The Yooper Goddess
  • Events
  • Programming
    • Programming Guide
    • CBS
    • MeTV
    • Start TV
    • Heroes & Icons
    • Court TV
    • ION
  • Station
    • About Us
    • Community Involvement
    • Mobile App
    • Meet the Team
    • Contact
    • Careers
    • Advertising
    • Request Copy of Story
    • FCC Public File
    • EEO Report
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our privacy policy.